Question on barding deed defense breakdown

[Leewald7]

Im getting two different sources stating different breakdowns.

First one is:
Iron 10%
Dull 11%
Shadow 12%
Copper 13%
Bronze 14%
Gold 15%
Agapite 16%
Verite 17%
Valorite 18%
Exceptional adds an additional 2%
For total of 20%
(Im having trouble relocating the link for this breakdown)

Second one is:
Non-Exceptional is 10%
Exceptional is 20%
Color doesnt matter
(The second one also has other wrong data though saying it costs only 750 ingots to craft and states thr dmg rating is the 5 elements of OSI so i dont think this is accurate.)

@eppy


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Bromista]

First one I can almost guarantee it.

 

[Leewald7]

Thats what i thought just want to confirm.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Sir.]

Was wondering if any staff could actually confirm either please? Was thinking of investing in these for my guild but depending on the actual setup it could be a deal breaker in one way or another.

@Shane @JoeB @eppy

My thanks!

 

[Bromista]

This was the first I have heard of option two it must have been an OSI thing. Option 1

 

[Sir.]

Well, what I think happened, and I could be wrong here, but did Dragon Barding Deeds come out with AoS, which changed the whole armor/damage system by adding fire dmg, energy dmg, etc? That would render the first method useless, I would think, unless there is missing documentation on the fire/energy/disease/etc dmg ratings barding deeds give for each metal type. So currently by todays modern era standards, option 2 would be correct me thinks. However, since we are more of a UOR core server rather than AoS and only have the simple ar/dmg system. This makes me think that it would be option 1 because it seems more logical with our system and the fact that the staff themselves would have had to created a custom system to accomodate our ar/dmg system when they implemented barding deeds. And which is why I beckon their seal of approval on either option 1 or 2, or explain a third option we have not tabled if they would be so kind.

 

[Young Star]

It is the first option. I dont feel like digging for it but that is what eppy wrote.

 

[Leewald7]

I agree i believe its option 1 since they dont do the 5 ele AR rating in this server and it costs well more than 750 ingots to make.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Leewald7]

@eppy which break down is correct? Do you know?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Young Star]

http://www.uoforum.com/threads/publish-6a-tweaks-and-changes.64900/

Its in here. Starts at 10% for iron. Maxes at 18% fir valorite. Exceptional gives 2%

 

[Sir.]

Thanks for finding that @Young Star